LitterMaid vs ScoopFree

We love to have pet whether it is a cat, dog, fish, rabbit, or any common house pets we can keep at home. For those feline owners who want to be very convenient, change your kitty’s litter box with LitterMaid Vs ScoopFree because they will make sure to keep the odor away and the litter stay clean for your fur friend. If you are also considering to choose one of them, see what they can offer below so then we can pick the best option.

In this article, we are going to give you information about:

  • How to Clean a Litter Box
  • What is Self-Cleaning Litter Box
  • What are LitterMaid and ScoopFree
  • What LitterMaid and ScoopFree Look Like
  • How are the Mechanism of LitterMaid and ScoopFree
  • Are LitterMaid and ScoopFree Noisy
  • How are the Performance of LitterMaid and ScoopFree
  • LitterMaid Vs ScoopFree

Litter Box Cleaning

Being a cat owner, we have been experiencing various moments with our fur babies and as adorable as they can be, there are things that can never be separated from a pet owner’s life and yes, it is about keeping the hygiene in the house including cleaning their litter box. Unlike your canine friend, our cat uses the litter box every day to relieve themselves and like all of us knew how cat loves clean places, a dirty litter box is an issue as well for them.

A litter box is a necessary part in our house and as you have to clean the toilet once in a while, this litter box needs to be cleaned often because cats love to use their litter box clean and it prevents them from using other areas in the house which we are sure you don’t want to as well. Cleaning litter box is fairly easy and quick with just a regular scoop and by picking all drops or lumps then put it in a bag and dispose outside. 

Don’t forget to wash the scoop as well after every application to reduce any unpleasant smell in the house and once in a while also wash their litter box with gentle soap or baking soda to properly cleanse the plastic.

Self-Cleaning Litter Box

It sounds like a hassle and yes, this is our sacrifice to have a pet because at the end we are the one who are responsible for their wellbeing. If you are looking into being more convenient without having to clean the litter box every day, especially those with more than one cat in the house, then why not try to consider getting a self-cleaning litter box. As the name suggests, they are a cat litter box with a feature to make sure the litter is always clean.

However, shopping for one is not as easy because there are so many of them out there and we have to pick the one that will fit the application we need. First thing we have to make sure is that they need to be large enough to fit your cat because not all are sized the same so those with bigger cats whether it is caused of breed like maine coon or because they are just a big chonky fella have to go with a wider litter box.

Another tips is whether the self-cleaning machine is working properly or not based on what their users have talked about them. In most cases self-cleaning litter box will produce quite a noise when operating and if the rake is dirty, the drops or lumps will stick together especially due to cat’s urine and failed automatic cleaning system. Overall, getting this seemingly convenient tool doesn’t mean that you will be free from the daily duty.

About LitterMaid and ScoopFree

Even with this automatic function, a litter box will still need to be regularly cleaned or once a day even faster if you have more cats in the house. Our favorite thing about the equipment is that we can do it less because many owners are not always present in the house and this little machine can replace your duty while you are away. It also keeps the litter clean and the room fresher because the waste are stored in a special chamber or storage.

Among those many litter box offered by different brands, LitterMaid and ScoopFree are two of the most popular today and it is not without a reason because many people who have been using them are also satisfied with their performance. Especially for LitterMaid, this brand is very popular and have been the favorite for many cat owners due to its reliability but, as they change the products material, it is not as great as it used to be. We also notice that some users are experiencing some malfunctioning on their products.

Even those who have been using LitterMaid for years are also stating that either the product has changed from the last time they have bought or the mechanism fail only after few months after purchasing. Similar issues are also said about ScoopFree but comparing them to each other, it seems there are less complaint with this model. In terms of mechanism both of them are very similar to each other just like any other automatic self-cleaning litter yet, we also find no special features that can add to their appeal.

LitterMaid and ScoopFree have a sensor that will detect when your kitty is using the box and will activate the cleaning system after they get out of the box but there is a time in between to prevent their rake moving while your cat is still inside. 

LitterMaid and ScoopFree Design

We are sure you can already guess the system by looking at their design and while there is no special aesthetic in any of these litter boxes, they are functional and simple. Both will come with their own litter package which you can try for the first few months and what’s special about ScoopFree is their litter particles also have this blue crystals to keep the odor away. On the other hand LitterMaid have clumping compound and the box itself is recommended to be used with this certain type of litter.

As for the product dimension, LitterMaid outer form is measured at 17 by 35 inches including the ramp portion but the litter area is only about 14 by 16 inches while the latter is measured at 19 by 27.3 inches with an inner area that can be used approximately measured at 14 by 14 inches. 

LitterMaid and ScoopFree Mechanism

Moving forward, let’s see how LitterMaid and ScoopFree work and in this side, as we have mentioned above, all litter boxes use the same mechanism combining a sensor with a rake movement to clean the litter compound. Once your cat enter the box and relieve themselves then leave, their sensor will pick up the movement and will wait for a certain time in this case 10 minutes and 20 minutes respectively. However, this time is not adjustable so the system will proceed as how they were preset.

Another difference is how the rake move because LitterMaid will lift the rake a bit higher to access the storage room and it will cause the litter compound to fall down while keeping the clump on top. On the other hand ScoopFree with its metal rake is working like any regular rake or flat with swiping motion while the waste compartment is enclosed on the other side. This room, similarly will open when the rake is approaching but unlike the former, its opening is on the same level as the tray.

LitterMaid and ScoopFree Noise

As for the noise level, all litter box are going to make a noise when operating and none of LitterMaid and ScoopFree are working quietly so be prepared to hear some weird noise while the unit is doing its job. They are equally loud and we don’t recommend putting them near your bedroom because your cat may use them at night and triggering the system. If you want the one with sleeping mode feature, go check our LitterMaid Vs Nature’s Miracle.

LitterMaid and ScoopFree Performance

Now let’s talk about their performance because this is the most important part to consider. Side by side LitterMaid and ScoopFree are very similar to each other whether it is from the design or mechanism. They will perform well in most cases but the amount of failed operation in LitterMaid makes many users have to change their litter more often or dealing with the mess just like when using a non-automatic litter box.

Issues we have is since the ramp take a good amount of its form factor, your cat my relieve themselves or urinating on top of it and not on the litter compound. In such case the urine will drip into your floor and the rake is made from plastic which often make the clump stick into it. ScoopFree on the other hand is using metal rake which is easy to clean and rarely get stuck but if the waste is soft there is a high chance it will stick into the rake as well.

In addition, the blue crystal ScoopFree use is very effective to eliminate odor because they will absorb urine and moisture from the waste. It is however will eventually lose its power and we also hope the blue crystal they put on the package will be sufficiently higher to beat the smell. One issue is your cat may not like this crystal if they are used to different types of litter.

LitterMaid vs ScoopFree

- MULTI-CAT SELF-CLEANING LITTER BOX: This litter box has automatic scooping with a rake that removes waste for a clean, fresh start. It is designed to be used with multiple cats over 15 lb.
- LOW MAINTENANCE: When used as directed, the LitterMaid Multi-Cat Self-Cleaning Litter Box requires no daily scooping, meaning you have a scoop-free clean up for up to 7 days.
- ODOR CONTROL: Once the rake removes waste, the waste receptacles with carbon filters keep mess and odor contained.
- LITTER BOX DESIGN KEEPS AREA CLEAN: Designed with high walls to prevent litter scatter and a paw cleaning ramp to help prevent tracking around the box.
- UNBEATABLE ODOR CONTROL: Crystal litter removes smell by absorbing urine and dehydrating solid waste
- NO MORE MESSY FLOORS: Low tracking crystals are 99 percent dust free and don’t stick to your cat’s paws
- LEAK PROTECTION: Disposable trays have plastic lining to help protect against leaking and keep your floors clean
- QUALITY GUARANTEED: PetSafe brand has been a trusted global leader in pet behavior, containment and lifestyle innovations for nearly 30 years; we help pets and their people live happy together

These self-cleaning litter boxes are a good choice if you want to be convenient but they are not perfect because there are some issues regarding their performance. ScoopFree is often better because it has thin metal rake which is sturdier and doesn’t get stuck often when scooping the waste. Its mechanism is simpler than LitterMaid because the rake is not lifting but only swiping the waste to its front compartment in which the latter lift its rake first before dumping the waste.


None of them are a perfect option but comparing the two we do prefer ScoopFree because it seems to last longer and more reliable while also especially good with the crystal litter in case your kitty can use them.